BarkBox Super Chewer Review 2026
Get BarkBox Super Chewer →Free replacement if destroyed · Cancel anytime
Our verdict
Best for tough chewers who want variety.
★★★★★ 9/10
Pros
- ✓Great variety and fun monthly themes
- ✓Good treat quality
- ✓Best unboxing experience of any box tested
- ✓Affordable on 12-month plan ($23/mo)
- ✓Super Chewer variant for tougher dogs
Cons
- ✗Standard toys don't hold up for power chewers
- ✗Super Chewer needed for tough dogs at higher price
BarkBox has been around since 2012 and is the most recognized name in dog subscription boxes. Their Super Chewer line is the one built for dogs that actually destroy things.
Standard BarkBox is designed for average dogs. Super Chewer is different — thicker rubber toys, double-layered plush, floss ropes, and tough chews. It's BarkBox's answer to the question: what do you send to the dog that destroys everything?
What's in the box
Every Super Chewer box ships with 2 fluff-free toys, 2 full-size bags of treats, and 2 bags of chews. The toys follow a monthly theme — BarkBox themes are genuinely creative and make the unboxing experience fun.
The toy materials are reinforced compared to standard BarkBox: thicker rubber, reinforced seams, no squeakers to immediately destroy. The chews are durable and last longer than standard treats.
How the toys hold up
Super Chewer toys hold up better than standard BarkBox, but they're not built for extreme power chewers. In our testing with a 65lb American pit bull terrier, Super Chewer toys lasted 1–2 weeks — significantly better than standard BarkBox (3–5 days), but still behind Bullymake's nylon and rubber toys.
For moderate to heavy chewers, Super Chewer is the right call. For dogs that destroy everything regardless of material, Bullymake is the upgrade.
Pricing
Monthly plan: $46/mo. 6-month plan: $39/mo. 12-month plan: $36/mo. First box discounts available — check their current offer.
The guarantee
BarkBox offers a satisfaction guarantee — if your dog doesn't love a toy, they'll replace it. Their customer service is responsive and the process is simple.
Who it's for
Super Chewer is the best choice for moderate to heavy chewers who want variety, themed boxes, and a fun unboxing experience. It's the right upgrade from standard BarkBox. For extreme power chewers that destroy everything, look at Bullymake — it's built for a harder problem.
Themed boxes built for dogs that chew hard
Super Chewer plan · 2 toys + 2 full bags of treats · Cancel anytime
Visit BarkBox Super Chewer →“The themes are so fun — my dog goes crazy every time the box arrives. Super Chewer toys actually last.”
Mike T.
Lab owner
About the Editor
Carl Thompson has owned dogs for over 20 years and has spent the last 11 testing gear with Ruger, his 72lb American Staffordshire terrier. Every product reviewed on Tough Dog Toys is based on real-world experience. Carl uses affiliate links to keep the site running.