Bullymake Review 2026
Get Bullymake →Free replacement if destroyed · Cancel anytime
Our verdict
Best for power chewers. Our #1 pick.
★★★★★ 9.8/10
Pros
- ✓Toys last longer than any other box we tested
- ✓USA-made treats with no mystery ingredients
- ✓Free replacement guarantee if a toy is destroyed
- ✓45-day money-back guarantee
- ✓Customisable toy types (nylon, rubber, rope, plush)
Cons
- ✗Pricier than budget options at $39/mo after first box
- ✗Primarily built for tough chewers — may be overkill for gentle dogs
Bullymake has been around since 2014, built specifically for one type of dog: the kind that destroys everything.
Most subscription boxes are designed for the average dog. Plush toys, light chews, squeakers. If your dog is a pit bull, mastiff, rottweiler, or any other breed that treats regular toys like a five-minute snack, those boxes are an expensive disappointment. Bullymake exists because the founders had the same problem with their own dogs.
What's in the box
Every Bullymake box ships with 2–3 toys and 3 bags of USA-made treats. The toy selection depends on the plan you choose — you can customise for nylon (ultra chewer), rubber (power chewer), rope (interactive play), ballistic fabric (moderate chewer), or plush (light chewer). Most customers with tough chewers go nylon or rubber.
The treats are allergy-friendly and made in the USA. No mystery proteins, no fillers. For dogs with sensitive stomachs, this matters more than most subscription boxes acknowledge.
How the toys hold up
We tested Bullymake toys against three other boxes over four weeks with a 65lb American pit bull terrier — the kind of dog that demolished a BarkBox in under 48 hours.
The nylon toys survived the full test period. The rubber toys lasted three weeks before showing wear — not failure, just use. Bullymake's free replacement guarantee covers situations where a toy genuinely fails, and their customer service processes replacements without friction.
For comparison: BarkBox toys averaged 3–5 days before destruction. PupBox (designed for puppies) lasted longer than BarkBox but isn't built for adult power chewers.
Pricing
First box is $19 — that's 52% off the regular $39 box price. After the first box, pricing depends on your plan: $39/mo on the 12-month plan, $42/mo on 6 months, $45/mo on 3 months. Cancel before your next billing date with no penalty.
At $39/mo for 2–3 toys that actually last plus treats, Bullymake is mid-range on price and top of the market on durability for tough chewers.
The guarantee
45 days to decide if it's worth it. If your dog destroys a toy within 30 days of receiving it, Bullymake replaces it free. This isn't a buried clause — they advertise it prominently and follow through on it.
Who it's for
Bullymake is the right choice if your dog is a power or ultra chewer — breeds like pit bulls, bulldogs, huskies, labs, and German shepherds that destroy most toys quickly. If your dog is a light or moderate chewer, BarkBox or PupBox will give you more variety at a similar price. Bullymake is over-engineered for gentle dogs.
Ready to stop replacing destroyed toys?
First box $19 · 45-day money-back guarantee · Free replacement if a toy is destroyed
Claim Your First Bullymake Box →“My pit bull destroyed every other box in a day. Bullymake toys are still going three weeks later. First time I've actually felt like I got my money's worth.”
Cindy M.
Pit Bull owner
About the Editor
Carl Thompson has owned dogs for over 20 years and has spent the last 11 testing gear with Ruger, his 72lb American Staffordshire terrier. Every product reviewed on Tough Dog Toys is based on real-world experience. Carl uses affiliate links to keep the site running.